In its never-ending quest to nickel and dime Houstonians out of every last dollar, the City of Houston recently announced that it will begin charging for some of the parking spaces at Memorial Park. The City has said that the revenue will help maintain the park. This is absurd on so many different levels that I hardly know where to start.
First, the numbers. The plan is to meter 572 spaces, about a quarter of the total spaces in the park. The charge will be one dollar for three hours. So, let’s assume all of the spaces were used 12 hours a day, 365 days per year. That would bring in about $800,000. Of course, it will not be anywhere close to that. From my experience going to Memorial Park, I would guess that a third of that time would be a generous guess. If so, that would bring in $200,000-$300,000 per year.
But, of course. all of that is not “profit.” According to the City’s latest budget, it spends about 63 cents for every dollar of parking fees it collects. So, in other words, the City will be lucky if it clears $100,000 per year from this venture.
That is about 2 thousandths of one percent of the City’s annual budget. Eliminating just one of the thousands of bureaucrats at City Hall would save us more than the revenue this incredible inconvenience will net.
Of course, the need for more money to maintain Memorial Park begs the question of where is all the money that the Uptown TIRZ was supposed to kick in as part of the 2013 deal to add ten years to its life (and to the misery of the Galleria residents). The current City-approved budget for the Uptown TIRZ has a measly $280,000 (less than 1% of its budget) for “Park Project Program Management.” God save us any more City project managers. How about hiring some guys to pick up the trash or maintain the roads and the trails?
Also, charging for parking is incredibly discriminatory against those who do not live close enough to walk or bike to Memorial Park. The City already spends a disproportionate amount of its parks budget on the “Golden Bowl” (a term dubbed by community activists for Buffalo Bayou, Hermann and Memorial parks – more on that in the near future). Charging outlying residents for access to Memorial Park exacerbates the discriminatory effect of City concentrating its park investments in the Golden Bowl.
Lastly, let me just assure you that this is the proverbial nose under the camel’s tent. What do you think the odds are that the City will be back in no time increasing both the number of spaces that will be metered and the hourly rate? And, of course, be prepared to pay a few parking tickets along the way.
The City does not seem to understand that most people have a choice of where they live and open businesses. For the last twenty years, the City’s growth has been declining, outpaced by its suburbs and other major cities in Texas. Last year it virtually ground to a halt, with the City only adding only 7,000 net new residents. And that was before Hurricane Harvey took its toll.
According to the Greater Houston Partnership, Harris County suffered a net domestic out-migration of over 45,000 residents last year.[i]
Obviously, the decision to charge for parking in Houston’s most iconic park is a trivial matter in and of itself. But it is symbolic and symptomatic of a larger issue. When you have high property taxes, widespread drainage problems despite residents paying $100 million per year in drainage fees, a police force that does not patrol most neighborhoods and only solves 6% of the burglary cases, streets that look like they should be in the Third World, ambulances breaking down on the way to the hospital . . . I could go on . . . at some point residents reach a breaking point and decide to vote with their feet. Clearly, for many residents, Houston has already reached that point.
[i] “Net Domestic Migration” is the number of individuals who move to Houston from other areas of the United States. It does not include individuals who moved here from a foreign country. The GHP reports that the net international migration for the County was a positive 34,000, resulting in a negative net migration for the County of just over 10,000. The Census Bureau does not break this down municipalities, so we cannot determine how much of out-migration for the County was attributable to the City only. [click here to full report].
Don’t forget to sign up for Bill King’s email list by clicking here.
The fight to improve Texas public education gets a boost from noted economist Dr. Ray Perryman. From the InBox:
The Lone Star State is attracting more major corporate locations than any other (and has for a number of years) and is adding jobs at a strong pace. Growth is broad based, covering the spectrum from cornerstone industries to emerging sectors. While I hate to rain on anyone’s parade, some recent statistics show one critical area where the state is falling behind: support for public education. If we don’t fix it, we will erode our advantage in the years to come.
The Census Bureau recently released the 2016 Annual Survey of School System Finances. It provides information regarding spending on public elementary and secondary school systems (including public charter schools). Of the 50 states plus Washington DC, Texas ranks tenth from the bottom in spending per pupil at $9,016, well below the national average of $11,762.
Part of the explanation is that most of the highest-spending states (such as New York, which is the highest at $22,366) are characterized by high costs of living in their major population centers. However, there are many states (such as Iowa, Nebraska, Montana, and South Carolina) that outpace Texas by a significant margin.
In instructional spending (basically teacher salaries and benefits), Texas stands at $5,514 compared to the US average of $7,160 (thirteenth from the bottom). While instructor salary is near the middle of the rankings, the employee benefits are literally the lowest in the nation (by a notable margin). Texas also spends far less on support services at $3,002 per student (the national average is $4,107).
Texas students’ college entrance exam scores are below national norms. According to Prep Scholar, the average SAT college entrance exam score in Texas was a 1020 of 1600, compared to a national average of 1060. The ACT also reported that the class of 2017 in Texas averaged a 20.7 composite score out of 36, below the national average of 21.0. These numbers are not catastrophic, but they do not bode well for the race to be a global technology player.
Texas increased total spending per student from 2015 to 2016, but only slightly (from $8,861 to $9,016). It was below the national average rise and certainly not sufficient to move up the rankings. While academic performance depends on more than just dollars, adequate resources are essential to quality education. Future prosperity depends on supporting public education and providing the funds to attract quality teachers and give them the support that they need. More folks who are raised in Texas stay here than in any other state. The kids we educate will either contribute to growth and competitiveness or be a drain on public and community resources. It is up to us!!
It is important to note that Dr. Perryman isn’t some radical left wing progressive economist. In fact, his work has been cited by Republicans for years.
The Republican Party of Texas convention approved a number of criminal justice reforms for the party platform:
The GOP platform calls for no Class C misdemeanor arrests except to prevent violence.
It requires a criminal conviction before any asset forfeiture.
It calls for the elimination of red-light cameras and other photo-enforcement systems
It called on the legislature to raise the age of adult criminal culpability from 17 to 18.
It called for an end to “the incarceration of individuals because they cannot pay tickets, fines, and fees for Class C misdemeanors, including traffic citations.”
It calls for the immediate restoration of the “driver licenses of the citizens whose licenses were suspended by the Driver Responsibility Program and to cancel their debt.”
It calls for crime labs to be sufficiently funded to reduce rape-kit processing times to 90 days.
It calls for the Legislature to require a warrant for the government to access cell-phone location data.
It calls for reducing penalties for low-level marijuana possession from a Class B misdemeanor to a civil fine.
It calls on Congress to remove cannabis from the list of Schedule 1 drugs.
It calls for “doctors to determine the appropriate use of cannabis for certified patients.” (In California doctors have determined that pot is a proper prescription for baldness, ingrown toenails, erectile dysfunction and just about any other kind of complaint.)
It calls on the Legislature to fully fund indigent criminal defense.
One would have to think that some of these planks were written by Democrats, not by Republicans. And it sure looks like the Texas Republican Party is moving toward the legalization of pot.
As the race for State Chairman of the Republican Party of Texas comes to a close, I wanted to share some last-minute news surrounding the race as well as some closing thoughts as the state convention approaches.
Vice-Chairman’s Race
Incumbent Vice-Chairman Amy Clark announced several months ago that she would not be seeking re-election to her position. There are currently two announced candidates for this position. Under RPT rules and the Texas Election Code, the State Chairman and Vice-Chairman must be of the opposite sex.
Here is a little bit about each of the announced candidates:
A longtime fixture in Bexar County Republican Politics, Alma-Perez Jackson served as a Republican Precinct chair for from 1987-2016 and was a member of the SREC from 2014-2016. Perez-Jackson has also been a Republican candidate for public office, having been the Republican nominee for State Representative District 125 in 2015 and a Republican candidate in the State Senate District 26 special election in 2015.
Former Republican National Committeewoman Denise McNamara was also running for Vice-Chairman until last week. McNamara’s campaign gained endorsements from Republican National Committeeman Robin Armstrong, current SREC members Stephen Broden (SD 23), Sue Evenwel (SD 1), J.T. Edwards (SD 11), and Mark Ramsey (SD 7), and the Conservative Coalition of Harris County. McNamara endorsed Jackson upon her withdrawal from the race and many of those who endorsed McNamara have followed suit in endorsing Jackson.
The only announced male candidate for Republican Party of Texas Vice-Chairman, Rangel has established himself as Cindy Asche’s unofficial running mate. A member of the SREC since 2016, Rangel was a candidate for San Antonio City Council in 2005, 2011, and 2015. Rangel also serves as a public member of the Broker Lawyer Committee of Texas Real Estate Committee, having been appointed to the position by Governor Abbott in 2016.
Although politically active for many years, Rangel is a newcomer to the Republican Party. Voting records obtained from Bexar county show that Rangel voted in a Republican primary election for the first time in 2012. Prior to that, Rangel consistently voted in Democratic primary elections.
Campaign finance records on file with the Texas Ethics Commission also reflect Rangel’s recent conversion to the Republican Party. Rangel made several contributions to the Northwest Democrats of Bexar County PAC between 2002 and 2012, with his last contribution made just one month before the 2012 Presidential election. Rangel did not begin making contributions to Republican candidates and organizations until 2015.
Rangel’s Facebook page touts endorsements from many of Cindy Asche’s biggest supporters including Asche’s mother, Donna Crocker, former RPT Chairman Tom Mechler, former RPT State Chairman candidate Rick Figueroa, and a handful of SREC members.
Anonymous Attacks Against James Dickey
Fred Rangel has also used his Facebook page to share content from “Texas Conservatives for Liberty and Freedom”, an anonymous Facebook page and e-mail list that has recently popped up as a vehicle for attacks on incumbent RPT State Chairman James Dickey. “Texas Conservatives for Liberty and Freedom” was soundly denounced by many conservatives for its use of strong invective and personal attacks against Dickey and graphic images it published portraying a villainous-looking Dickey alongside splattered blood.
Cindy Asche’s campaign even attempted to distance itself from the tactics of “Texas Conservatives for Liberty and Freedom”, issuing the following statement:
Our campaign received several questions about an email that was sent out about my opponent this morning and some social media posts that have followed.
I want to make it abundantly clear that neither I nor my campaign consultants or staff were aware of this group’s existence prior to the email this morning, nor do we know who is behind the group. This content was sent out without our knowledge or approval.
While we have provided information on relevant legal issues related to this race, every statement we have made has been backed up by extensive legal documentation. We do not condone smear campaigning.
At this point, we do not know if the person behind this is trying to help our campaign or hurt it by making it look like we are running a smear campaign.
If you receive any questions about the email or Facebook ads, please refer people to this statement. Let us know if we can provide any additional clarity.
Despite this denunciation, Rangel and many of Asche’s most prominent supporters have not hesitated to disseminate these smears against Dickey.
Campaign Fundraising and Spending
The recently released “8-day” campaign finance reports, covering campaign activity between May 6th through June 4th reflect James Dickey’s campaign having raised $35,509, spent $33,712, and no outstanding debt and Cindy Asche’s campaign having raised $1,900, spent $141,421.50, with $145,613.38 in outstanding debt (all personal loans) during this reporting period.
Asche’s extraordinary self-funding of her campaign has raised many eyebrows, especially since the office of State Chairman is a volunteer position and she has not previously been actively involved with Republican Party of Texas activities nor been a major donor to the Republican Party of Texas.
While Asche and her supporters have called Dickey’s fundraising ability into question and claim that Asche will be able to attract major donors to the Party that are not currently giving, Asche’s lack of fundraising for her own campaign calls into question whether she would be able to successfully raise funds for the Republican Party of Texas if elected. To the extent that Asche has raised money for her campaign, nearly half of those raised funds ($6,000) have come from former RPT State Chairman Tom Mechler.
Closing Thoughts
As I wrote here several weeks ago in a post defending James Dickey against unfair personal attacks lodged against him by the Asche campaign, I expressed my desire that the contested race for State Chairman would elevate to a contest of ideas about how to grow and strengthen the Republican Party of Texas. Unfortunately, this has not occurred.
Particularly troubling to me are the accusations from the Asche camp that many hardworking grassroots activists who have spent many years working within the Republican Party to grow the party and promote limited government, pro-family public policy are somehow Libertarian infiltrators who have worked to hijack the Republican Party and promote abortion and marijuana use. This rhetoric is not only wholly meritless (the vast majority of liberty-minded Republicans I know are strongly pro-life, just as Ron Paul and Rand Paul are), but completely undermines the message of party “unity” they claim to promote.
It’s also peculiar that they would accuse longtime Republican Party volunteers of trying to “infiltrate” and “hijack” the Republican Party, but at the same time embrace and promote the Vice-Chair candidacy of Fred Rangel who was voting in Democratic Party primary elections and making financial contributions to Democratic organizations in San Antonio when these liberty-minded Republicans were hard at work to bring new voters to the Republican Party and oppose the disastrous Obama agenda.
While this race has been unnecessarily divisive, we must not lose sight of what is at stake in November. Democratic candidates across Texas, and particularly Harris County, are increasingly embracing socialism openly and disparaging those who practice traditional Christianity. The Republican Party must make a clear distinction between pro-growth, limited-government policies we stand for and the socialist views espoused by many on the Democratic ticket. We must embrace those who have previously been apathetic politically or have been turned off by the Democratic Party’s shift to the far left.
While I personally support James Dickey, I know many of Cindy Asche’s supporters to be good people who care deeply about the success of the Republican Party at the ballot box and the Republican Party platform in the halls of the legislature. Despite the heated rhetoric of the campaign, it is imperative that all Texas Republicans unite around the Party leadership elected by the state convention delegates. Our time and effort after the convention must be focused on fighting Democrats, not other Republicans.
The Republican Party of Texas (RPT) has long had its fights at the state convention about who will lead the Party going forward. In the past, all types of conservatives have been welcome to join in the fight to beat the Democrats and keep Texas Red. In keeping with that approach, when the Libertarians came into the Party through Ron Paul’s Presidential Campaign, they were welcomed to join the effort to fight Democrats. Only with this group, something was different. Their interest wasn’t in fighting the Democrats, but rather was vested in the opportunistic use of the Republican Party.
The warning should have been clear when they accidentally included the 2014 State Convention Platform Chair in an email chain, which included “since the Libertarian Party is a lost cause, we should join the Republican Party and take it over.” That way they could use its resources and ballot box name acceptance to elect Libertarian candidates running as Republicans. And so, the battle began as they implemented the tactics of Saul Alinsky outlined in his book “Rules for Radicals.” Tactics which include: 1) If you push a negative hard and deep enough it will break through into its counter side, 2) Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it, and 3) Ridicule is man’s most potent weapon. And they have followed his beliefs that “the end justifies almost any means” and “truth … is relative and changing.” Unfortunately, many good conservative candidates on the receiving end of these relentless attacks can attest to the brutality of their use. And honesty in the minds of the Libertarian activists? What does honesty have to do with anything when the goal is to win? In keeping with Alinsky’s tactics, if something negative can’t be found, make something up!
The most recent statewide director of Ron Paul’s campaign ran and was elected to the State Republican Executive Committee (SREC) along with several other Libertarians. They proceeded to get themselves and their followers placed on the 2016 State Convention Rules Committee. They knew that the Rules Committee’s report is almost never changed on the floor of the state convention. And so, the most dramatic change was made to Rule 44, which was modified to allow the RPT to attack any elected official in the primary that was censored by majority vote of the state convention or 2/3 vote of the SREC. The Democrats have to be dancing in the streets over how the Libertarians have done something they could never accomplish- tear the mighty Republican Party to pieces.
Also, at the 2016 Convention, they were able to get their followers elected to the SREC by which they proceeded to elect Libertarian backer James Dickey, State Chair when the former chair resigned for personal reasons. Dickey won by one vote by misleading the SREC at the previous night’s candidate forum (James Dickey Dismissal of Republican Party of Texas Officers ).
The pattern of the Libertarians in Texas has been to take over successful, conservative organizations and use them to attack Republicans. The mode of operation has always been the same: recruit candidates regardless of qualifications, who will do what they tell them, then viciously attack the incumbent Republican using whatever means necessary, lying about the opponent as required. This article is pretty accurate in its description of the Libertarians’ efforts in Texas: Beilue: Empower Texans – It’s like a season of ‘House of Cards’. Hopefully, the 2018 Convention delegates will put a stop to the destruction of the RPT before it’s too late.
The personal views of Janet Jackson are from her Party experience, having served on the SREC from 2010 – 2016 and as President of the Texas Republican County Chairmen’s Associations for 2016 – 2018 and are not on behalf of any organization mentioned herein.
I’ll let these two press releases on the tensions between religious freedom and gay rights speak for themselves:
Log Cabin Republicans Response to Masterpiece Cakeshop Decision
Washington, D.C. — Moments ago, the United States Supreme Court issued its long-awaited opinion in the case Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. In a 7-2 decision, the court ruled on narrow grounds, concluding that Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Phillips was treated with undue hostility because of his sincerely held religious beliefs.
In response, Log Cabin Republicans President Gregory T. Angelo issued the following statement:
When faced with the contentious issue of balancing religious freedom and LGBT equality, today the Supreme Court wisely decided to hit the pause button. There will be many on the left who will say that this ruling opens the door to rampant discrimination, and many on the right who will declare that this is a major milestone for advocates of religious liberty — but neither will be correct. The fact that Justices appointed by Presidents Clinton and Obama sided with Masterpiece Cakeshop should be an indication that there is more nuance to this decision than meets the eye. In writing for the majority of the Court, Justice Anthony Kennedy declared the ‘outcome of cases like this in other circumstances must await further elaboration in the courts’; we look forward to that day. More than anything else, the Masterpiece Cakeshop decision shines a spotlight on the glaring absence of federal LGBT non-discrimination legislation. Log Cabin Republicans remains committed to passing such protections while also honoring the religious liberty upon which our nation was founded.
and
Texas Values: Cake Baker Supreme Court Victory! Religious Freedom Clause Key To Historic Win
Washington, D.C. —This morning the U.S. Supreme Court released its decision, holding 7-2 that the Colorado government violated the constitutional rights (Free Exercise Clause) of private business owner and cake baker Jack Phillips. Last year, Texas Values joined 32 state family policy organizations from across the country supporting Colorado cake shop owner Jack Phillips, a supporter of traditional marriage who is being forced by the government to make a cake with a specific theme: celebrating a same-sex wedding ceremony.
“This is an important religious liberty victory for a private business owner who prevailed over the wrongful attempts of the government to punish Jack Phillips for his faith. This decision will go a long way to helping Texas lawmakers pass state law protection on these specific religious freedom attacks from local government laws like Dallas, Austin, and San Antonio, just to name a few. The First Amendment protects religious liberty and freedom of speech and does not give government power to force artists such as Jack Phillips to express someone else’s message, particularly on an issue such as marriage that has been widely debated in our country,” said Jonathan Saenz, Lawyer and President of Texas Values.
Notable quotes from the opinion:
“The reason and motive for the baker’s refusal were based on his sincere religious beliefs and convictions.”
“To Phillips, creating a wedding cake for a same-sex wedding would be equivalent to participating in a celebration that is contrary to his own most deeply held beliefs.”
“[T]he religious and philosophical objections to gay marriage are protected views.”
“[G]overnment has no role in deciding or even suggesting whether the religious ground for Phillips’ conscience-based objection is legitimate or illegitimate.”
Background:
A May 2014 order by a state of Colorado government entity, the Colorado Civil Rights Commission, goes much further than simply ordering Phillips to “accommodate” the wishes of two men who in 2012 asked Phillips to design a wedding cake to celebrate their same-sex ceremony during a 30-second visit to Phillips’ store. Phillips is required by a Colorado government entity to re-educate his staff — most of whom are his family members — essentially telling them that he was wrong to operate his business according to his faith. He must also report to the government for two years, describing all cakes that he declines to create and the reasons why. As a result of this order, Phillips has lost an estimated 40 percent of his business. The Colorado Supreme Court declined to take the case after the state’s Court of Appeals affirmed the order. The U.S. Supreme Court case is Masterpiece Cake Shop v. Colorado.