Gov. Rick Perry has appointed Jeff Brown of Houston as a justice of the Supreme Court of Texas for a term to expire at the next general election.
“Jeff is an outstanding and accomplished jurist whose highest priority on the bench is preservation of the rule of law,” Gov. Perry said. “Jeff is a staunch defender of the constitutional freedoms our state and our nation are founded upon and he will uphold these values with honor, dignity and integrity as a Supreme Court justice. I am pleased he will continue his lifelong commitment to public service and the people of Texas by accepting this appointment.”
Brown is currently justice of the 14th Court of Appeals, a position he has held since his appointment in December 2007. He is also presiding judge of Harris County Success Through Addiction Recovery Drug Court No. 1. He is a former judge of the 55th Judicial District Court in Harris County, and a former associate attorney at Baker Botts LLP. Brown served as law clerk to Texas Supreme Court Justices Jack Hightower and Greg Abbott. He is vice chair and past president of the Houston Law Review Board of Directors, treasurer of the Texas Supreme Court Historical Society, and past president of the Texas Association of Civil Trial and Appellate Specialists. He is a member of the American Law Institute, Federalist Society, State Bar of Texas Pattern Jury Charges Committee, LifeHouse Advisory Board, and Supreme Court of Texas Multidistrict Litigation Panel. He is also vice president of the University of Houston Law Alumni Association and a former adjunct professor at the University of Houston Law Center. He is an editorial board member of The Advocate, a life member and committeeman of the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo, past board member of Texas Lyceum and a graduate of Leadership Houston Class XVIII.
Brown received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Texas at Austin and a law degree from the University of Houston Law Center.
And:
Dear Friends,
Today I am excited to announce Gov. Rick Perry has asked me to serve on the Supreme Court of Texas. My appointment fills the vacancy that occurred when Gov. Perry appointed Justice Nathan Hecht as Chief Justice. I am honored and grateful for the opportunity to serve on Texas’ highest court.
I know I am joining a court whose distinguished members share my belief that judges should be scholarly and impartial, that they should follow the law, and that they should wield the powers they employ with humility, restraint, and a deep respect for constitutional principles. For the last several years I have had the honor of serving on the Fourteenth Court of Appeals and I am proud to say that it is a place of dignity, scholarship and good humor. Together my fellow justices and I have worked hard to bring fairness and justice for everyone in our ten-county district. Growing up, a sense of service and respect for the law was instilled in me as I watched my father serve the people of Texas as a Dallas police officer. I am proud to be, like he was, a servant of the people of Texas. Judges should first and foremost be devoted to the rule of law, duty-bound to follow the law and not legislate from the bench. That’s the kind of justice I try to be everyday, and that’s the kind of justice I’ll be on the Supreme Court.
Sincerely,
Jeff Brown
This couldn’t have happened to a more deserving candidate in a million years! If you haven’t met Jeff, or reviewed his demeanor on the court, you might not have a clue. I supported him when he ran for the Texas Supreme Court and he almost made it to the runoff that year. You simply cannot find a better all around person than Justice Jeff Brown.
Congratulations Jeff! Wow, wow, wow, wow! Sometimes the good guys win!
After Monday night’s council meeting, one of the residents told me that he was looking forward to my recap and could I please include pictures of circus animals. I couldn’t think of any response other than ‘how the heck do I write about this?’ But alas, I will try and as usual, go in the order of the agenda. BTW, you can now listen to the meetings online buy clicking on the little speaker icon on the meetings page.
Special Presentations
City Administrator Stall went over the proposed budget. There isn’t anything that I can add to this that I didn’t write about earlier. The only thing that I will say is that I was disappointed that Stall presented it because it is Mayor Webber’s budget. He should have been the one explaining why he wants to deficit spend. And I did say that in the meeting.
Administrative Reports
Stall described a boating accident that resulted in a death. Shoreacres PD responded to the call at the Houston Yacht Club.
Business
8.2 – this agenda item is something that Alderman Nancy Schnell has been working on for a couple of months. In a nutshell, the city currently has, by code, one building inspector. Not a company, an individual. So, if he isn’t available when your contractor is ready to move to the next step, you have to wait. Schnell’s ordinance starts the process to expand that list. Although citizen Dana Woodruff spoke in opposition to it, it passed the council unanimously.
8.3 – Alderman Schnell volunteered to be the representative to the Houston-Galveston Area Council. Alderman Mike Wheeler volunteered to be the alternate.
8.4 – Budget review
Here is where the real ‘fun’ started. I’d suggest that you listen to the meeting if you want to get a real flavor of what happened. In the end, another budget workshop was scheduled for Monday, September 30th.
Here are a few of the things that got my attention.
Mayor Webber wanted to go line item by line item but that proved unworkable and tedious. In fact, I don’t recall that they ever got off the first line item. Alderman Schnell wanted to look at the big picture and started out by saying we needed to cut the city secretary to 29 hours a week and that we couldn’t afford the current city administrator.
Citizen and former alderman Dana Woodruff gave a spirited defense of Mr. Stall, noting the amount of funds that he had pulled in via grants after Hurricane Ike and the progress made on rebuilding streets, water infrastructure, and drainage ditches.
Citizen Ron Hoskins stated that he had pulled budget numbers from the city website and noted the large increases in spending since 2008. He then proposed returning to the budget of 2008. That isn’t a bad idea if you ask me. I’d rather have zero-based budgeting but it is probably too late in the process for that to happen on this budget.
Then someone mentioned that Stall himself had said that the city would be broke in two years. Stall objected and asked the mayor if he could clarify what he said. In addition, he objected to “someone” (yours truly) using budget numbers and not actual numbers when analyzing the city’s financial situation. Imagine that, using budgets that council approved to analyze the direction of the city. Shame on me.
Stall continued, saying that we haven’t thrown the money away, we’ve invested in assets and rebuilding infrastructure. I’ll let you listen because I’m fair that way. I am also posting the charts he used to “prove” that I was wrong.
This is the way he described it to me via email:
At the instant the budget year ends all there are fund balances that include cash, bank balances, TexPool and the Certificates of Deposit. For that instant there is no budget and no reserve, just fund balances. In the next instant the new budget goes in to effect and those funds that are not budgeted for expenditure become the reserve (unbudgeted cash reserves).
The numbers on the chart are the fund balances at the end of one budget as the next is ready to start.
Fair enough. I stated that the city’s reserves had dropped 30.4{997ab4c1e65fa660c64e6dfea23d436a73c89d6254ad3ae72f887cf583448986} over the past six years, including the current year through August 31. Stall’s combined chart also uses six years but he goes back to a year before the hurricane and doesn’t include the current year, which isn’t exactly apples to apples but I’m fair, so I’ll accept it. Using his method, the city’s combined funds have only dropped 28.1{997ab4c1e65fa660c64e6dfea23d436a73c89d6254ad3ae72f887cf583448986}. Do you think that is rosy?
Now, about his ‘clarification’. I’ve transcribed what he said at that budget workshop but please, listen for yourself to see if I described it accurately.
If you look at the big picture and you put both of the funds together, you can see that the combined growth of the budgets is 3.9{997ab4c1e65fa660c64e6dfea23d436a73c89d6254ad3ae72f887cf583448986} and you can see that the contribution from the reserve fund is $846,000. As we look forward, that is not a sustainable number even if we come in under budget. We have in reserve just slightly more than $1.7 million, so if we were to spend all of the money in this budget, which we historically have not done, but if we were, and if our revenues were to come in at or below, we would only have one more year that we could have this kind of deficits and fund it from the reserves.
I absolutely agree with him that this is not a sustainable number. I completely disagree that we should budget spending more than we know we will spend just so that we can say that we are ‘under’ budget. This type of budgeting leads to terrible decisions, such as the witch-hunt against the current police chief, for which the council approved spending $15,000. One of the council members told me that he voted for it because they didn’t have to go out and find new money, they just used money that was budgeted. I’m sorry but budgeted or not, that $15,000 came straight out of the reserves. No legitimate business in the US would put up with this kind of budgeting.
Stall and I are like oil and water on most things. As Chair of the Fayette County Republican Party, he works inside the system. As a political blogger dealing mainly with Republicans, I work outside it. He uses Canon, I use Nikon. But I respect his wealth of knowledge and have stood in front of council many times and said that we are fortunate to have him as our city administrator. Whatever comes out of the budget talks, my opinion of him will not change.
Commentary
There were other highlights but too many to mention. I do like the aggressiveness that Schnell and Alderman Steve Jones are displaying in insisting that the budget be balanced. I was disappointed that Mayor and a couple of others stated that they were not interested in affecting the livelihoods of city employees. I’m sorry but this is the City of Shoreacres, not the Texas Workforce Commission. As Mr. Hoskins stated, sometimes you have to cut a few jobs to protect the majority of the jobs. No one said being on council would be a walk in the park – we need people that are willing to make decisions to protect the future of the city.
Here is my suggestion to each council member. Show up at the budget workshop Monday night with your own budget. Present it to the other members. This will be far less time consuming than going line by line. If you don’t have the time to come up with your own budget, do as Mr. Hoskins suggested and present the 2008 budget as is. Have Mr. Stall put your proposed budget on the city website Friday or Saturday so that other council members and citizens could review it before the workshop. Citizens will not have input at the meeting because it is a workshop but they could contact council members and let them know that they approve or disapprove of their proposals. Heck, I’ll be happy to highlight the proposals here. Anything to avoid another ‘circus’ like we saw Monday night.
We have serious budget problems. But we also have plenty of knowledge and creativity to overcome them. Let’s Git-R-Done!
As you have undoubtedly heard by now, Texas Gov. Rick Perry appointed Devon Anderson to succeed her deceased husband Mike as the Harris County District Attorney. Judge Anderson is certainly qualified for the job, having been a prosecutor, a judge, and a criminal defense attorney during her career.
The Houston Chronicle’s headline writer has been having a rough time of it lately. This is the headline and subhead from Brian Rogers’ article on the appointment:
Perry taps Anderson to serve out late husband’s term as DA
Anderson will complete term of her husband
That headline is incorrect. Devon Anderson may or may not serve out or complete the term of her husband – that decision will be up to the voters of Harris County. First she will have to survive a primary and if the way her husband ran his race is any indication, it will be brutal. I don’t think that whomever runs against her will make the same mistake that Judge Pat Lykos made and not respond to attacks until it is too late. Oppo research guys are already sending stuff out about Mrs. Anderson. If she makes it out of the primary, she will have to win in November against an energized Democratic Party.
That November election is one of the reasons for her appointment. By all accounts, she is a good campaigner and the hope is that she, along with Harris County Judge Ed Emmett, will be able to get Republicans to the polls and offset the energy that Sen. Wendy Davis will bring to the Democrats. On the surface, it is a good theory. But like any political theory, it has flaws. I can think of two of them right off the bat.
First, is she pro-life? Like it or not, the pro-life faction of the Republican coalition is critical to the success of Republican candidates. Jared Woodfill, Harris County Republican Party Chair, sent me a text message assuring me that she is pro-life. If that is true, then she will not take the path of her husband and refuse to answer questions about the judicial bypass hearings that were held in her court. And she will need to explain how she will approach cases like the Douglas Karpen case differently than her husband did. If she can’t or won’t answer these questions, the pro-life faction will not support her and that will hurt the entire ticket. Unlike the caricature of pro-life voters that persists in the media, this group is not comprised of uneducated trailer park trash and they won’t be fooled. She must be completely transparent and honest with this group.
Second, I admit that I had a few good laughs yesterday as some supporters of Judge Belinda Hill immediately changed their tone and told us that Mrs. Anderson was the most qualified person for the job. Prior to the appointment, they were rabid supporters of Judge Hill. Mrs. Anderson’s appointment will bring out the usual accusations that the Republican Party discriminates against blacks. In fact, the very first comment on the pro-Anderson website was this:
I suppose the party line on the Republicans’ shameful passing over of Belinda Hill—the most qualified candidate, but also a black female in a party run by old white men—is that “she doesn’t want the job.” Here’s to hoping that she dispels that falsehood, even if she waits until after her ouster.
“I understand that Judge Anderson and Judge Hill discussed this extensively,” said Chip Lewis, an attorney who supported Mike Anderson in his run for office last year.
“They both believed that this was in the best interest for Harris County and their families to move forward with this arrangement,” he said.
Well, we’ll see about that. I filed a Public Information Act Request with the Governor’s office this morning for copies of the applications that were submitted seeking the appointment.
And don’t you find it interesting that the Harris County District Attorney’s Office has yet to issue a press release on the appointment? I do.
I’m always amazed at the way “professional media” goes after public figures, tearing them down and ruining their reputations as they chase a “story”. They trumpet their efforts with outrageous and misleading headlines and teasers, throwing caution to the wind in an effort to get more readers, listeners, or viewers. Or perhaps, like one beat writer in Houston, trashing politicians in the hopes of being on the “inside” if their guy wins.
And then when the truth comes out and their sensationalism is proven to be false, which is typically long after the public flogging, the silence is deafening. But silence or not, the truth matters. So I’ll tell you, even if the sharks in the media will not.
Recall that Chip B. Lewis made a big deal out of suing former Harris County DA Pat Lykos and Assistant DA Rachel Palmer for what he claimed was “unlawful retaliation”. This was on the heels various folks, including some in the media, using Judge Susan Brown’s Runaway 185th Grand Jury to help Mike Anderson defeat Lykos in the Republican primary.
Federal Judge Lynn Hughes dismissed this frivolous lawsuit with prejudice on August 30th.
A dismissal with prejudice is dismissal of a case on merits after adjudication.The plaintiff is barred from bringing an action on the same claim. Dismissal with prejudice is a final judgment and the case becomes res judicata on the claims that were or could have been brought in it.
A court has inherent power to dismiss an action with prejudice if it is vexatious, brought in bad faith, or when there has been a failure to prosecute it within a reasonable time.
But there were few mentions in the Houston media about this. The bloggers that helped the 185th Runaway Grand Jury didn’t blog about it. Just silence.
If the Port of Houston bans cruise ships because of your protests, the longshoreman who has no work as a consequence cannot sue you. Similarly, you are not immune from natural consequences of your free speaking, especially if it affects people’s impression of your abilities, including reliability. Lykos and Palmer were obliged as public servants to recommend a supervisor for the alcohol testing. Neither had the power to interfere with Culbertson’s and Wong’s employment at Lone Star College.
This tortification of politics and related public administration fails.
I waited. And waited. Those that attacked Lykos and Palmer remained silent.
But the key point is that ADA Palmer CLEARLY wants to get to the truth. Let me repeat what she says on the record:
Respectfully, it’s more important than that. Let me make clear for the record, I am not unhappy with this witness. It’s important that the State knows the truth about what’s going on in the Houston Police Department crime lab.
Virtually the entire universe of press surrounding the BAT Vans, DA Lykos, and ADA Palmer has accused them of trying to hide something or cover something up – in reality, as documented in the official trial transcripts. they were trying to get to the truth about them. If nothing else comes from this lawsuit, perhaps that point will make it through the noise.
Unfortunately, I don’t think that point has made it through the noise. As a political figure, Pat Lykos had to endure the humiliation of the false attacks – it comes with the territory. But the people that did this to ADA Palmer, who wasn’t a political figure, should have had to pay a price by going to jail. Yet even today, she is still being attacked by those that refuse to see the truth or the error of their ways. The so-called “stain” on her reputation should be considered an attribute – she stood up to a bullying judge and grand jury and said I’m not going to go along with your farce of an investigation. Sometimes standing for what is right will have lesser people calling you names and mocking you – it is a weak person’s way of dealing with the fact that they would not be strong enough to do what you did.
Congratulations to Judge Pat Lykos and ADA Rachel Palmer for their victory. It should never have gotten this far in the first place but you held firm and showed your true character. I pray that your futures are blessed and bright.
Contrary to this report from Brian Rogers in the Houston Chronicle, the Harris County Republican Party, aka the Harris County GOP, is remaining neutral in the appointment process for the vacant Harris County District Attorney position. In a smackdown of Harris County Republican Party Chair Jared Woodfill, the party’s executive committee, which is comprised of precinct chairs, approved a resolution put forth by Precinct 661 chair Tom Bazan at their quarterly meeting last night.
The resolution was not about Mrs. Anderson. It was about the Party chair once again going around the party’s leadership. As for why Woodfill did this in the first place, he is supposed to return my call inquiring about that. But my guess is that he is trying to make up with the Anderson faction that split the party so badly in the 2012 primary in order to help himself in the 2014 primary. Remember, Woodfill supported Pat Lykos in that race. Which makes this quote from Deborah Wrigley’s report on ABC 13 humorous at best:
“I’m looking for someone qualified, who shares Mike’s vision and can run for election. She meets all those criteria,” Harris County GOP Chair Jared Woodfill said.
Seriously Jared? Someone who shares Mike’s vision of the good ol’ boys days of lock ’em up and throw away the key while withholding evidence from defense attorneys? Talk about a filp/flop. That is 180 degrees from your comments during the 2012 primary.
Good for the precinct chairs asserting their power. That is a positive sign for the future of the party.
I know, I know, I promised to move all of these Shoreacres posts to a different site. Well, forgive me but I decided it was just too much trouble to keep up with another site. Sue me. Or just skip this one. But maybe you shouldn’t because I doubt Shoreacres is alone as a city with major budget problems.
Recall that at the budget meeting on September 10, Mayor Matt Webber proposed a budget with an overall increase in spending of 3.9{997ab4c1e65fa660c64e6dfea23d436a73c89d6254ad3ae72f887cf583448986}. The members of the council that were present balked, holding the line at the old tax rate and promising to cut spending to match it. Even with that commitment the budget would increase by about 2{997ab4c1e65fa660c64e6dfea23d436a73c89d6254ad3ae72f887cf583448986}.
At tomorrow night’s council meeting, Mayor Webber is scheduled to present his budget to the public. I’m assuming that the proposed budget that he will present is the same one as he presented on September 10th because there is no updated proposed budget in the council packet or on the website.
This is one of those times that I have to blame myself for not understanding just how severe the budget problems are for the city. I should have been going to these meetings in years past. The problems the city faces are severe, to say the least. We have been running budget deficits for years but especially since Hurricane Ike hit in 2008. Some of that was offset by grants received from various state and federal agencies but incredibly, we continued to increase our spending even as the city’s population and property tax base dwindled. As I’ve found over the past few days, it is a difficult tale to tell but I’ll attempt it.
First, here is a table showing that how much our reserve fund has dropped since 2008 – I could not go back further because the information isn’t available on the city’s website:
The 2013 balance is as of August 30th, the rest are at September 30th of their respective years. As you can see, the fund has dropped by 30.4{997ab4c1e65fa660c64e6dfea23d436a73c89d6254ad3ae72f887cf583448986} in the past six years. This is because the fund was used to supplement the ongoing operations of the city.
Here is a chart of General Fund revenues vs expenses for the past 11 years plus Mayor Webber’s proposed budget for next year:
Click to enlarge. The red bars are budgeted expenditures, the green budgeted revenues less budgeted reserve fund transfers. Here is a table of numbers if that is better for you:
The Utility Fund is probably worse because it is supposed to generate enough revenue from sales of water and sewer services to pay for itself:
And a table of values:
What this all means is that we have been using our reserve funds to run the city. The reason that we aren’t at zero reserves already is because of the grants mentioned above. But recall that during the September 10 budget meeting, City Administrator David Stall warned council that we would be at zero within two years if they do not cut spending or raise taxes and fees.
Another interesting feature of the budget is that the Utility Fund has been used to subsidize the General Fund. Look at the amount of funds transferred from the UF to the GF:
According to the budget detail, these transfers are supposed to reimburse the General Fund for the costs associated with running the water, sewer, and refuse collection departments. The average cost for this charge was $35,152 from 2002-2010. The charge increased substantially after that to an average, with Mayor Webber’s proposed increases included, of $135,213. Obviously the cost to the city didn’t increase this much. Either the definition changed or council decided to subsidize the General Fund. I think it is the latter because I recall some discussion of that after the hurricane.
Okay, that is a lot of stuff to ponder. The main thing that you need to ask yourself as a citizen is why would the Mayor propose an increase in budgeted spending if the finances are this bad?
What we should be doing is cutting spending and cutting it drastically if we have any chance of surviving as a city. Raising taxes isn’t an option because of the high rate that we already pay. Raising water and sewer fees is an option for that fund but as I review line items, there are opportunities for major cuts that should be done first. Don’t forget that we are gong to have to replace our water tower, which is estimated to be over a million dollars. At the budget meeting, Stall stated that we would have to issue bonds for that replacement. Folks, if we continue down this path, no one is going to buy bonds we issue – they will be classified as junk bonds.
Please attend the meeting Monday night, September 23rd. Perhaps the Mayor can explain why he wants to raise spending by dipping further into our shrinking savings account. Perhaps council will see the light and demand immediate, deep cuts to the budget.
I’m not trying to scare you – I’m simply presenting to you what Mayor Webber is proposing. And I’m trying not to be too critical of Mayor Webber – after all, I stood in front of council and urged them to vote for him as Mayor Pro-Tem after the previous mayor resigned. I simply think that it is a huge mistake to increase spending and use our reserve funds for non-emergency items and think that it will hurt the future of the city. If there is a future at all.