In case you missed it, the Houston Chronicle published an editorial slamming Harris County Republican Party Chair Jared Woodfill and his “ilk” for opposing the sexual predator protection ordinance that Annise Parker is pushing through Houston City Council. Since I’m an “ilk”, I think everyone should read Woodfill’s very articulate response. It is hard to believe that the Chron ed board dismisses legitimate opposition to the ordinance as “hatred” towards the transgendered community.
Chronicle Editorial Board Demonizes Those Opposed to the Mayor’s Sexual Predator Protection Act
Jared Woodfill
In a recent OpEd titled, “Pass the NDO,” the Houston Chronicle Editorial Board criticizes me and others for opposing an Ordinance pushed by Mayor Parker that would allow, among other things, men who identify as women to use women’s bathrooms and locker rooms. Specifically, the Board states, “Perhaps Woodfill and his ilk would like Parker to institute citywide restroom monitors to assuage their fears.” This is preceded by a subtitle that states, “There is little value in spreading hatred about the transgender community.”
Whenever and wherever sexual politics is involved, labels are employed to shoot down valid questions about the impact of legitimizing certain activities in the public sphere. The latest in this long string of debates involves Mayor Parker’s proposed city ordinance that would allow, among other things, men who claim to identify as women to use women’s restrooms, locker rooms and other gender-specific facilities.
I, like tens of thousands of other Houstonians, oppose the Ordinance. This coalition is very diverse, including Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, Tea Party activists, pastors, priests, fathers, mothers, daughters and just about any group you can think of that takes issue with, among other things, gender confused men using women’s bathrooms. Unfortunately, the Chronicle Editorial board has decided to describe me and anyone else who opposes allowing men into women’s restrooms as “hateful.” The discussion is then shifted away from the merits of the proposition and turned into a mudslinging contest where the best ad hominem attack wins. Name calling is no replacement for facts.
And the fact is, passing an ordinance that allows men claiming to be gender-confused to enter women’s restrooms is dangerous. What about the rights of the affected women to not be exposed to men while in restrooms, locker rooms, or other gender specific facilities? Indecent exposure and assault in restrooms are already very real and quantifiable problems, but in the case of the proposed ordinance, it is the chicken or the egg: wrong is wrong and right is right, and women should not have to contend with male genitalia in their restrooms or private space.
The current discourse is not about “hate” or “intolerance,” but about common sense, a quality not in large supply these days. Do we really want our daughters and wives to be forced to contend with men in their personal space? Semantics and hypotheticals about what these men may “feel” about themselves are irrelevant. What about the very real problem of the risk inherent in declaring open season on women’s restrooms for any and all men who can put on a dress?
After Mayor Parker’s latest change to the proposed ordinance, men can now enter women’s facilities even without female attire. Various editorials by transgender activists are now painting those opposed to the Ordinance as “non-discrimination opponents,” essentially accusing those who oppose men using women’s restrooms of “discrimination.” We are not opposed to stopping discrimination or promoting equality. But that is not what the so-called, “Equal Rights Ordinance” accomplishes. Far from it: this ordinance imposes another form of very real discrimination on businesses and people of faith, and puts innocent civilians in the path of sexual predators.
From one “ilk” to another, well said Jared. Anyone that doesn’t think perverts will take advantage of this ordinance to enter women’s locker rooms is naive and should remember that perverts are very sick people. And as my wife asked me last night, what happened to my rights as a woman? She’s right. For centuries men’s rights came before women’s and only in the last century or so have we made progress in that area. Not protecting women is going backward. Shameful.
Before I talk about the candidates in this race, let me explain the purpose of the misdemeanor courts. There are fifteen misdemeanor courts, also known as county criminal courts, in Harris County. These courts hear class a and b misdemeanors, which include the following types of cases:
driving while intoxicated cases for first and second offenders;
possession of marijuana;
theft and criminal mischief under $1,500;
burglary of a motor vehicle; and
criminal trespass.
These courts handle thousands of cases each year and serve as the front line in the intervention process. Most capital murder defendants have been guests of these misdemeanor courts before they enter the big boy criminal courts. That being said, it is crucial that these misdemeanor court judges are experienced, thoughtful, good judges of character, and smart.
The two candidates in the County Criminal Court at Law 10 race are Dan Spjut and Tonya Rolland McLaughlin. Both candidates have their own strong points.
These are both good candidates for different reasons. Dan Spjut is a 25-year law enforcement officer who fought through long odds to obtain a law degree. Dan was a highly regarded police officer who worked as an undercover narcotics detective for ten years at the Houston Police Department. Currently, he is a lawyer in private practice has focused his practice on juvenile law. In the primary election, Dan was in first place and came close to winning the election without a runoff.
Tonya Rolland McLaughlin is a former prosecutor and, now, a practicing criminal defense lawyer. Her trial experience is extensive and she has a lot of support at the courthouse from her peers on both sides of the courtroom.
I love the questions that are asked at the Downtown Pachyderm because they reflect the knowledge of the audience and the enthusiasm of the candidates’ supporters. In this crowd, folks are not shy; so, I always try and make these forums.
Of course, this forum, like many before it, included the dreaded slate question. Every candidate who knows anything should be prepared for Ann Lee’s ubiquitous marijuana question. Of course, there are the typical experience and consultant questions. And, certainly, I always ask a question.
Both Dan and Tonya admitted to paying the slates for ads. This is an often-asked question it is rare when a candidate refuses to pay the slates. Anthony Magdelano was the latest to use this as a principle in his campaign. Unfortunately for him, he was unsuccessful.
Neither Dan nor Tonya wanted to see marijuana use expanded though legalization and both wanted reform through decriminalization. There is no reason to ruin people’s lives through convictions and labels.
One of the questions I liked was about punishment. Both candidates expressed that each case needs to be looked at separately and that deferred adjudication is appropriate in certain cases for first time offenders. Repeat offenders should be dealt with more harshly. Both candidates are qualified for this bench.
This race is important and I encourage you to do further research. I know my colleague, Dave Jennings, has interviewed both candidates and will soon publish those interviews.
Hmm. Perhaps I was too quick to accept Mayor Annise Parker’s “compromise” on the sexual predator protection act as a good thing. At least that is what Jared Woodfill and the rest of the gang opposing the ordinance think. From Jared’s email after the “compromise”:
Jared Woodfill
After hearing from tens of thousands of Houstonians opposed to Mayor Parker’s Sexual Predator Protection Act, the Mayor recently claimed she was removing the “Bathroom Language” (Section 17-51(b)) which allowed gender confused individuals to utilize the bathroom associated with their gender identity/preference or expression regardless of their biological sex. The Mayor claims she is compromising on her original position. Unfortunately, Mayor Parker’s personal, social agenda dominates her decision making and one must study the language of the Ordinance to appreciate the deceptiveness of the alleged compromise. The Mayor’s “compromise” actually makes the Ordinance more egregious and dangerous to our families.
Even if Section 17-51(b) (“Bathroom Language”) is removed from the ordinance, places of public accommodation will still be required to allow biological males to use the women’s restrooms, locker rooms, and other facilities. Even worse, businesses will be forced to allow more biological males into the women’s facilities than if Section 17-51(b) is not removed.
Section 17-51(a) makes it “unlawful for any place of public accommodation or any employee or agent thereof to discriminate against any person on the basis of any protected characteristic.” The Ordinance defines discrimination: “to distinguish, differentiate, separate or segregate…any person on the basis of a protected characteristic.” (section 17-2) “Gender identity” is a protected characteristic under the ordinance. Therefore, if the Bathroom Language is removed, places of public accommodation that do not allow all who claim to be women, regardless of biological sex, to use the women’s facilities could face criminal charges of discrimination pursuant to Section 17-51(a).
To make things worse, the Mayor eliminates the “good faith” defense provided to businesses under Section 17-51(b). This means that places of public accommodation will be forced to allow biological males who present as male (regardless of whether they are dressed as females) to use women’s facilities, since the ordinance prohibits discrimination because of gender identity. Removing Section 17-51(b) and its “good faith” defense will allow more biological males into the women’s facilities, not less.
This is just one of many reasons I have previously articulated that justify defeating our term limited Mayor’s last ditch effort to push her personal, social agenda on the City of Houston. Please call, email, and fax all City Council Members and the Mayor immediately. Thank you for standing tall!
Dave Welch’s group, the Houston Area Pastor Council, put out a legal opinion backing up Jared’s interpretation:
May 13, 2014
David Welch
U. S. Pastor Council
P.O. Box 692207
Houston, TX 77269
Re: Removing Section 17-51(b) (the “Bathroom Language”) from Mayor Parker’s Ordinance will allow MORE biological males into the women’s facilities, not less.
Dear Mr. Welch:
Even if Section 17-51(b) (the “Bathroom Language”) is removed from Mayor Parker’s Ordinance, places of public accommodation will still be forced to allow biological males to use the women’s restrooms, locker rooms, and similar facilities. In fact, they will be forced to allow even more biological males in the women’s facilities than if Section 17-51(b) is not removed.
Section 17-51(a) makes it “unlawful for any place of public accommodation or any employee or agent thereof to discriminate against any person on the basis of any protected characteristic.” To “discriminate” means “to distinguish, differentiate, separate, or segregate … any person on the basis of a protected characteristic.” (Ordinance § 17-2.) “Gender identity” is a protected characteristic. So even without the Bathroom Language, places of public accommodation that do not allow all who claim to be women, regardless of biological sex, to use the women’s facilities could face charges of discrimination pursuant to Section 17-51(a).
Section 17-51(b) provides a good faith defense to businesses that deny biological males access to the women’s facilities when they do not express themselves as female. Removing Section 17-51(b) also removes that defense. As a result, places of public accommodation will be forced to allow biological males who present as male (i.e., are not dressed as female) to use the women’s facilities, since the Ordinance prohibits discrimination because of gender identity (not gender expression). Removing Section 17-51(b) and its good faith defense will thus allow more biological males into the women’s facilities, not less.
Very sincerely yours,
ALLIANCE DEFENDING FREEDOM
Joe La Rue
Legal Counsel
15100 N. 90th Street
Scottsdale, Arizona 85260
Jonathan Saenz of Texas Values sent out his own interpretation:
Jonathan Saenz
Houston, TX, May 14, 2014 – Today, Mayor Annise Parker and the Houston City Council will vote on theproposed wide-reaching LGBT ordinance that she has fast tracked through the council process. The proposed ordinance is a threat to public safety, Christians, and the private sector of Houston. The ordinance would give government new power to force private individuals and businesses to affirm homosexual conduct and actual or perceived “gender identity” or face serious criminal penalties, will allow men access to women’s bathrooms and locker rooms and some provisions may also be enforced against churches. The Houston City Council will meet at 9 a.m. today.
Mayor Parker announced yesterday that certain language that specifically applies to bathroom access by transsexuals would be proposed to be removed today. The language is still currently in the ordinance. And in fact, other portions of the ordinance still give transsexuals rights to the bathroom they choose, but now there is now “good faith exception” if a business owner makes a mistake about the sex of the person entering the bathroom or shower room. See more detailed analysis below. Legal experts agree, this change in the ordinance will allow MORE men to enter women’s bathrooms!
Numerous faith and local community leaders spoken out against the proposed LGBT ordinance and over 64,000 email message have been sent to council members against the ordinance.
Texas Values Action president, Jonathan Saenz, released the following statement:
“The Mayor’s last minute trick is no surprise. This is all part of the deception and effort to punish people of faith and give transsexuals and others a weapon to advance their sexual lifestyle with no limitations. This ordinance is still a major a threat to public safety, is an expansive overreach of big government and violates the rights of private citizens and we expect the City Council to vote for common sense and vote this ordinance down.”
Taken together, these releases are certainly enough to make you stop and think. Especially when you take a look at Mayor Parker’s Twitter feed and see what she tweeted regarding the language removed:
To my trans sisters/brothers: you’re still fully protected in Equal Rights Ordinance. We’re simply removing language that singled you out.-A
Well then. It looks like Jared, et al, are correct in their assessment. BTW, for a treat, click on that link to her tweet and read the discussion. Goodness.
Here is the real question: In a city that has potholes big enough to swallow small cars and “brownouts” with no coverage from the Houston Fire Department, why in the world are the mayor and city council pushing this completely unnecessary measure?
You want to know why I supported Jared Woodfill for another term as the Harris County Republican Party Chair? Because he isn’t afraid to stand up for what is right and what the majority of Harris County Republicans support. Being a spokesperson for the party is critical – I fear that in the future, obnoxious provisions such as letting men cruise women’s restrooms will pass because no one will be there to stand against them. Jared fought and fought hard against the ordinance and specifically that obnoxious provision. Today, Houston Mayor Annise Parker dropped the provision.
Conservative groups have taken issue with a paragraph that states: “It shall be unlawful for any place of public accommodation or any employee or agent thereof to intentionally deny any person entry to any restroom, shower room, or similar facility if that facility is consistent with and appropriate to that person’s expression of gender identity.”
Make no mistake, this would not have happened without Jared’s involvement. It saddens me that some Republicans in Harris County criticized him for his opposition to the measure. As a father of two daughters and now one granddaughter, I appreciated his efforts. I reached out to him and he was still not happy because he wants the entire ordinance to be defeated.
I was encouraged by the thousands of individuals who stood against the Mayor’s liberal, personal agenda for the City of Houston. We will soon find out whether she is listening. Regardless of the result, this is just one battle in a larger cultural we must win!
While I agree with his ultimate goal and wish that the Mayor of Houston would concentrate on fixing potholes, I still think that his efforts were very much worthwhile. And I’m very disappointed that Paul Simpson, Chair-elect of the Harris County Republican Party, remained silent on the issue.
Look, I’m very much on record as supporting a national NDO law and in support of two individuals, regardless of sex, being able to marry and live their lives without discrimination. But the idea that the intimacy of little children going to a restroom can be violated by perverts under the guise of “law” is revolting. And my revulsion has nothing to do with transgendered people – if you have already had the surgery, obviously you have ‘put your money where your mouth is’ so to speak, so that is a non-issue. Men entering women’s restrooms and then claiming that they are protected because Annise Parker says so is ridiculous.
It looks like voters are finally taking a good look at Attorney General candidate Ken Paxton and aren’t liking what they see. As I said earlier:
Paxton presents himself as some sort of Boy Scout Sunday School teacher. And thus far, the press has let him get away with that persona. I hope more journalists get interested in Paxton’s business dealings and bills he filed as a state representative. Perhaps then the voters will see Paxton for what he is instead of the fairy tale they think they know.
The Allen Police Association on Tuesday withdrew its endorsement for attorney general candidate Ken Paxton, citing last week’s reprimand and $1,000 fine for a state securities law violation and Paxton’s failure to publicly address the issue.
“We were troubled when we learned last week that the Texas State Securities Board determined that Ken Paxton had violated state securities law and, in response, issued a formal reprimand for his professional misconduct,” an announcement signed by association President Matthew Johnson said. “As law enforcement officers, we can no longer support Ken Paxton.”
“This is a criminal offense which could possibly be tried by the presiding district attorney or even possibly the Office of the US Attorney General,” McKinney Police Association stated in a release signed by president Jose Quiles and the political action committee chairman Farrel Ritchie.
“Given that the attorney general is the chief law enforcement officer in the state of Texas, the McKinney Police Association feels it is necessary to protect the integrity of the AG office and can no longer support Ken Paxton for attorney general,” they said in a statement.
But it’s the company contract with the state of Texas that seem to ensnare Cook and Paxton in an unlawful conflict of interest. The provision that would apply here is Article III, section 18, which prohibits “members of the Legislature from being interested, either directly or indirectly, in any contract with the State, or any county thereof, authorized by any law passed during the term for which he shall have been elected.”
As you can see by reading that article, ethics problems are nothing new for Ken Paxton. It’s interesting that people “in the know” talk about how Dan Patrick will bring down the R ticket in November if he is the nominee for Lt. Gov. even though polls do not show that happening. The same people ignore the damage that having an ethically challenged, unqualified nominee for Attorney General will do to the ticket. The Democrats in Texas have taken notice, as demonstrated in this tweet by Philip Martin, Deputy Director for @ProgressTX:
It would be a shame if down ballot candidates on the Republican ticket in urban areas lost their races because of a bad candidate at the top of the statewide ticket. Tea party groups need to take a second look at Ken Paxton because the more you know, the more you run away. Just like those two groups of police officers.
First it was former Mayor Dolly Aorns putting out a letter that skewed the facts of Shoreacres’ financial situation. Now it is current Mayor (and soon to be former) Matt Webber doing the same. Sometimes you just have to shake your head and wonder what universe people are living in because it isn’t reality.
If you were one of the “lucky” ones to receive Webber’s letter, you already know what I’m talking about. If not, then click here to read a desperate attempt to bankrupt the city. Don’t ask me for the reason why they want to bankrupt the city, I’ve been trying to tell people how to stop it.
I could pick this thing apart in a hundred ways but why? Voters either know the truth by now or they don’t. Fact: the person that wrote this letter, Mayor Matt Webber, proposed a budget that would have spent all but $15,000 of our $954,000 in liquid reserves this year. That is a FACT, as you can read for yourself if you care to. No spin, no hyperbole, no rhetoric. FACT.
In the letter, he includes a table that he says the city paid for which justifies the current salary of the City Administrator. Problem is that the table was never presented to the public or to council in an open meeting. Plus Webber asserts that this study was commissioned by former Mayor Arons before she resigned but given to someone in the city in June 2013. I guess that the “someone” would have been Webber himself because Arons resigned from council on May 28, 2013. Read about it. Oh, and about that salary? Council under Arons approved it in December, 2012, so why the so-called study in June 2013?
Webber gets quotes from former Mayor Jayo Washington, former Mayor Dolly Arons, and former Alderman Richard Adams. I find it interesting that each of those people voted for deficit budgets. I think Jayo is a good guy but he hasn’t been to a council meeting in a couple of years. I also find it interesting that in her letter trying to scare voters into voting for the status quo, Arons said that the current City Administrator was responsible for $7 million in grants from various agencies but in this one, she upped the figure to $9 million. I’m guessing that if the election wasn’t being held Saturday, we might be up to $20 million soon!
As far as I can tell, David Stall isn’t on the ballot Saturday. We are electing a new mayor and council. There are stark differences between the two mayoral candidates. There are stark differences between one candidate for council, Paul Croas, and the other three. I urge any citizen to contact each candidate and find out what they stand for and why. For what it is worth, only one of the four candidates I interviewed even brought up David Stall and that was Richard Adams. Richard told me that he wanted to investigate the allegations that Stall was “doing bad things” and that he wanted to review the policy of buying new vehicles every two years. In this letter, he credits Stall for the two year policy. You know, because every other city and law enforcement agency in Harris County is stupid to keep their cars so long.
And when you ask them about the budget, think about the fact (FACT) that Mayor Webber and David Stall proposed spending all of Shoreacres reserves this year. And they did this knowing full well that we would be insolvent if we did so. That isn’t rhetoric, that is fact (FACT). Listen to David Stall in HIS OWN WORDS:
If you look at the big picture and you put both of the funds together, you can see that the combined growth of the budgets is 3.9% and you can see that the contribution from the reserve fund is $846,000. As we look forward, that is not a sustainable number even if we come in under budget. We have in reserve just slightly more than $1.7 million, so if we were to spend all of the money in this budget, which we historically have not done, but if we were, and if our revenues were to come in at or below, we would only have one more year that we could have this kind of deficits and fund it from the reserves.
That is a transcription of what he said in the audio link above. The $1.7 million he mentioned includes four CD’s and checking account balances. In reality, we have less than a million in liquid reserves, which would have been liquidated this year if his and Webber’s budget would have been adopted. Fortunately, council cut that in half. Unfortunately, council cut that in half and refused to fix the problem. The only member of council that tried to fix the problem this year was Alderman Nancy Schnell. FACT.
Look folks, all I can do is give you information. I can’t tell you how to vote. I can only hope that you do your due diligence and vote on merit and not on popularity.